Annuities are a form of retirement income product, meaning that they provide you with a stream of income in your retirement years, similar to superannuation or an account-based pension. But unlike superannuation or account-based pensions, which both draw from a balance which fluctuates with the market, an annuity pays you a fixed amount at set intervals.
If that sounds like an attractive option to you, here’s everything you need to know about annuities and their various pros and cons.
What’s an annuity?
First and foremost an annuity is a product, which you purchase from either a super fund or life insurance company with a lump sum, using either money from your superannuation or regular old savings.
Once purchased, the annuity will provide you with income payments which can be made monthly, quarterly, half-yearly, or yearly. The amount you are paid mostly depends on how much money you’re willing to put towards the annuity, but the company selling you the annuity will most likely run some actuarial calculations which may end up adjusting the price slightly.
Your annuity can be set to increase each year, either in line with inflation or by a fixed percentage – this will again be contingent on the size of the lump sum you’re willing to put towards the annuity.
Why choose an annuity?
Annuities have a few features which make them an attractive option compared to superannuation or an account-based pension, but they also come with a few downsides.
The pros of annuities
One of the benefits of an annuity it that can be arranged either for life or for a set period – you’re offered flexibility with how long you want it to last, and subsequently how big of a lump sum you want to put towards the annuity.
The major upside of an annuity is that once it’s arranged and paid for, you’re set. Annuities are locked in once they’re paid for, meaning that unlike superannuation or an account-based pension (which are both market-linked investments), a market crash won’t scuttle your comfy retirement. You’ve got yourself a reliable, static income for either the rest of your life or the period that you arranged the annuity for.
If arranged to last for the entirety of your life, an annuity will provide you with consistent and steady income until you pass away. There’s zero risk of it running out, or of you outliving it. This is one of the most significant benefits of an annuity when compared against superannuation or an account-based pension.Both superannuation and an account-based pension can be depleted to zero before the end of your life, leaving you broke (with the possible exception of Age Pension payments).
All of that being said, annuities do come with some notable downsides.
The cons of annuities
While proponents of annuities view their non-market-linked nature as a big plus, that’s also their main flaw in the minds of many. While market-linked investments are inherently risky, they also have the potential to earn much more in interest compared to a fixed-return investment such as an annuity, which can be sold with an earning rate of as little as 2.5% p.a. By comparison, the S&P/ASX 200 is currently showing a 7.4% yearly return.
Additionally, annuities present several issues of liquidity and flexibility:
- Many annuity providers do not allow for lump sum withdrawals from an annuity, meaning that you lose access to your capital, and may find yourself unable to deal with large unexpected expenses
- If you decide to withdraw your funds entirely and cancel your annuity, it’s unlikely that you’ll receive the full amount still sitting in your annuity
- For example, investment management firm Challenger’s maximum withdrawal guarantee rates are 100% for someone aged 65-70, but 70% for a 75-year-old, and only 20% for an 80-year-old
- Depending on the provider and product, any funds leftover when you die may not end up being payable to your dependents or next of kin
- This is the default case for most annuities, so unless you negotiate a minimum payment term which goes past your death, an annuity won’t provide any rollover funds for your beneficiaries
- You have no say over where your money is invested if you put it into an annuity – for those concerned with ethical/green investing, this could be an issue
At the end of the day, annuities are a static and fixed form of investment, and that can be either a pro or a con depending on your individual circumstances and the kind of retirement strategy you’d like to pursue.
If you want a retirement income stream which provides you with more flexibility and transparency and you’re willing to deal with some market-related risk, you may be better off sticking with regular old superannuation.
The following table contains details of the superannuation funds rated by Canstar based on someone aged 40-49. This table has been sorted by one-year performance (highest to lowest)
Please note that the performance information shown in the table is for the investment option used by Canstar in rating of the superannuation product.
Canstar considers the annual investment returns of a product’s default investment option, including default life-stage options. Where a product does not have a default investment option, annual returns for the investment option with the highest FUM and a 60-80% growth asset allocation are used.
You might also consider account-based pensions, which you can compare with Canstar.