canstar
canstar
Some partners pay us, which may affect sort order, but never our ratings or awards.

Answer a few questions to refine these results

Get started, opens in a new tab
Showing results forNSW & ACT for 30 - 39
Star rating
Agreed or market
Price guide
NRMA Insurance
Star Rating
$$$
Average
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 24 months old

Read the PDS & check suitability.

ROLLiN' Insurance
Star Rating
$$$
Generally lower
  • Only monthly premiums are offered
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 14999 kms

Read the PDS & check suitability.

NRMA Insurance
Star Rating
$$$
Generally higher
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 36 months old

Read the PDS & check suitability.

BUPA Insurance
Star Rating
$$$
Average
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 24 months old

Read the PDS & check suitability.

ANZ
Customer Award
Star Rating
$$$
Generally higher
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 36 months old

Read the PDS & check suitability.

Bendigo Bank
Not Rated
$$$
Generally higher
  • Pay monthly at no extra cost
  • Rental car available (if at fault, not at fault, following theft)
  • New car if written off before 36 months old

Read the PDS & check suitability.

Showing 6 of 21 results

To see more results adjust the filters above

  • Included
  • Not Included
  • Optional
  • Not applicable
  • Canstar Star Rating

Unsure of a term in the above table?

Additional filters may have been applied, which impact the results displayed in the table - filters can be applied or removed at any time.

Compare from a range of car insurance providers

provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo
provider logo

We do not compare all brands in the market, or all products from our participating brands. At times certain brands or products may not be available or offered to you. Learn more.

A better way to compare pay-by-the-month car insurance

Teal Scales

Comparing is free and easy

Use our car insurance tools to compare a wide range of policies in our database quickly and easily.

Teal icon verified

Backed by expert research and ratings

Our research experts analyse and rate car insurance policies and highlight the providers offering real value.

Teal icon directions car

Find car insurance for you

Filter your search results to find car insurance policies tailored for you.

How to compare car insurance better with Canstar

A woman about to enter her car by a scenic mountain road, her hair billowing in the wind.

Discover our latest award-winning car insurance providers

2026 Outstanding Value Award
award logo
Car Insurance - AustraliaCar Insurance - SACar Insurance - VICCar Insurance - WA
2026 Most Satisfied Customers Award
award logo
Roadside Assistance - NSW
2026 Most Satisfied Customers Award
award logo
Car Insurance - NSW

Better deals are found when you compare

Canstar helps millions of Australians each year compare and find better deals

Google Logo

Rated 4.3 / 5

by our customers on Google Reviews

Based on 329 reviews

Product Review

Rated 4.4 / 5

by our customers on ProductReview.com.au

Based on 452 reviews

Ratings as of 14/10/2026

Pay-by-the-month car insurance tips from our expert

The months could add up

Pay-by-the-month car insurance could be an excellent way for Aussies to break down their premiums into bite-sized chunks. However, some insurers charge may charge you more to pay your car insurance monthly — typically because of instalment loadings or fees. A few insurers do allow monthly payments without adding extra fees, but check each policy’s details to be sure.

Set the date

If you’ve settled on a pay-by-the-month car insurance policy, automate your direct debits. If your insurer lets you choose a debit date, select one shortly after your pay comes in where possible. 

Cover exactly what you need 

Before choosing a car insurance policy, first assess what you need cover for. If you have an active car insurance policy, ask yourself if you’re paying too much for cover you don’t need or to maintain a low excess.

Guide to pay-by-the-month car insurance

What is pay-by-the-month car insurance?

Pay-by-the-month car insurance is not a standalone product. Instead, it refers to policies that allow you to pay your premiums in monthly instalments.  

Typically, car insurers offer monthly and annual payments, with the latter often being the default option.


What are the pros and cons of pay-by-the-month car insurance?

Pros

  • Flexibility: If you’re planning to switch policies or providers in the near future, paying monthly can means you don't pay a large lump sum upfront.

  • Lower upfront cost: In the short term, spreading your premiums across 12 months may be more forgiving on your budget. 

Cons

  • Extra costs: Depending on the insurer, you may be charged more overall than if you were to pay annually. However, not all providers charge extra for monthly car insurance payments.

You can use the table above to compare car insurance policies with the option to pay monthly at no extra cost. 

You should also read any relevant policy documentation, such as the Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) and Target Market Determination (TMD), for any policy you’re considering.


How much is a monthly car insurance policy?

The cost of a pay-by-the-month car insurance policy will ultimately depend on factors such as:

  • The type of policy (like comprehensive, third party fire and theft or third party property damage) and level of cover chosen 
  • The personal details of the driver or drivers listed on your policy
  • The make and model of the vehicle you are insuring
  • Your address, including where the vehicle is parked during the day and night
  • The excess (the amount you contribute towards a claim) listed in your policy (a higher excess can lead to lower premiums, but you’ll pay more if you need to make a claim).

How much more do monthly car insurance payments cost compared to annual payments?

Providers may charge you an extra fee, such as a regular admin fee, for the privilege of paying monthly. You may also be charged a higher base premium. 

Exactly how much extra you could pay for making monthly payments varies in line with: 

  • Your choice of provider
  • Your age
  • Your gender
  • Your location
  • The make and model of your car.

If you choose to pay your premiums monthly, you’ll typically still be committing to a 12-month policy with the provider. While you can generally cancel at any time, some car insurers may charge policy cancellation fees.

Note that not all providers will charge extra to access a monthly payment option. That’s why it’s important to speak to your provider or read your policy’s PDS to understand the costs to expect.

FAQs about pay-by-the-month car insurance

Paying for car insurance on an annual basis is the default payment option offered by most providers, but some may offer the option to split that annual cost into monthly payments.

However, paying your car insurance premiums upfront for the year means you don’t have to worry about ongoing payments. More importantly, you could be paying a lower total premium than if you paid monthly. 

It’s worth noting that Compulsory Third Party (CTP) insurance, also referred to as Green Slip insurance in NSW and Motor Accident Injuries (MAI) Insurance in the ACT, can’t usually be paid by the month.

Generally speaking, this type of car insurance usually needs to be paid as an annual lump sum or a six-monthly payment, typically alongside your vehicle’s registration. The frequency in which you can pay your CTP premium will depend on the state or territory your vehicle is registered in.

If you’ve missed a monthly payment, your insurer may send you a few reminders.

Typically, you’re notified at least 14 days before an insurer cancels your policy. Alternatively, if your payment is one month overdue, they can cancel your policy without any notice. 

Some insurers may even deny claims 14 days after a missed payment. 

If you’re struggling to meet your monthly payment obligations, immediately notify your insurer. They may offer you practical solutions such as a payment plan.

If you’re taking out a new policy, you can usually choose how often you’d like to pay when you get a quote or purchase your cover. Look for a payment frequency option during the application process, as annual payments may be selected by default.

Once you’ve got your policy, monthly payments are usually made by direct debit from your bank account, credit card, or debit card. Some insurers may also let you pay via BPAY, over the phone, or at an Australia Post office.

If you already have a policy and want to switch to monthly payments, you may be able to do so by:

  • Logging in to your online account or app
  • Contacting your insurer by phone or online chat
  • Making the change when your policy is due for renewal

But keep in mind, not all providers allow you to switch payment frequency mid-policy, so you might need to wait until renewal rolls around.

About our car insurance experts

Kevin Goh is a Senior Finance and Energy Journalist at Canstar who strives to demystify the ever-evolving energy and finance sectors for Aussies. Kevin has a BA in Journalism and a BA in Economics and International Relations from the University of Queensland. He also has half a decade of experience in the comparison industry and as a professional content writer for digital agencies such as Vesanique, Sea Salt Marketing and the Boys Creative Studio. You can follow Kevin on LinkedIn.

Tara Donnelly is Canstar's Managing Editor, Utilities, leading the team that focuses on energy, telecommunications and consumer technology. For more than a decade she has authored hundreds of articles covering these topics across Australia, the US and Canada, including seven years as part of the Canstar Group. Her expertise has seen her appear in national media including 9 News, 7 News, Sunrise, the ABC , The Australian Financial Review, 4BC Radio and The Sydney Morning Herald. Tara has been nominated for multiple awards for her technology reporting, including Canstar’s highly commended recognition for Best Consumer Technology Coverage in 2024. She has a Bachelor of Communications from the University of Canberra and is passionate about simplifying complex subjects so consumers aren’t just informed, they’re connected and confident. You can follow Tara on LinkedIn.

Important Information

For those that love the detail

This advice is general and has not taken into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether this advice is right for you.

Fight back against rising costs

Stay on top of the news that counts when it comes to your bills. We’ll send you expert tips, insights and the stories that matter. Unsubscribe anytime.

By proceeding, you agree that Canstar Pty Ltd & its subsidiaries collect, handle, hold, use & disclose your personal information to provide services to you, including marketing, in accordance with our privacy policy which explains how you may exercise your privacy rights.

Follow us