Opinion: Canstar’s General Manager of Wealth, Josh Callaghan
It’s now been nine months since Bitcoin’s stratospheric rise in price and chatter, so I thought it might be a good time for us to review what’s happened since and reopen the book on Bitcoin.
First let’s take a look at the price. For simplicity of picking up the data, I’m just going to report in US dollars but the AUD chart looks much the same.
Prepared by Canstar. Source: Coindesk.
This time two years ago, Bitcoin was trading at around $600. Halfway through December 2017 it got up to the famous $20,000 mark, and after crashing this February to around $7,000 it’s more or less travelled sideways ever since. In fact, you might say that since February the currency has somewhat stabilised given its range of trading has effectively been between $6,000 – $10,000, and averaging around $7,500.
The interesting thing about this, in terms of investing, is with this sort of price movement it is starting to look like a mature product. However, the remarkable thing about the price of Bitcoin is that there isn’t a fixed number of coins. Unlike shares in a company where there are only a certain number on offer, Bitcoins are continually mined. Therefore, a stabilised price is actually adding value to the market capitalisation of Bitcoin with every new coin mined. To break it down simply, think of it in terms of supply and demand. Typically, the value of an item reduces as there is greater supply, however Bitcoin has managed to maintain its value despite a continual supply.
There are many possible reasons the price of Bitcoin has declined since topping out in December. But the thing that leaves me wary about Bitcoin, comes down to the fundamentals of the technology, specifically the cost of mining a coin and the time it takes to settle a transaction.
The promise of Bitcoin was to provide lightning fast, near-free transactions without banks, central authorities or boundaries. Therefore, for me, the speed and cost of transactions has been my reference point to test if the technology is delivering what it had promised.
HOWEVER, in late 2017/early 2018, as transaction speeds were grinding to a halt and the transaction costs were skyrocking, the Bitcoin community started trying to redefine what its purpose was. Even Bitcoin.org subtly changed its homepage to position the coin away from its original promise. They subtly removed the reference to ‘fast’ transactions and completely removed their claim of low processing fees.
What is the future of Bitcoin? This is the critical question that anyone considering buying should think about asking, because the answer to this question may determine how you value it. Personally, I don’t know the answer. Right now, it’s a slightly faster but possibly more expensive way of transferring money across borders without the middle men. Although, if you want to use fiat currencies the middle men still exist in the form of crypto exchanges.
Sure, you can buy Bitcoin and use it at a lot more places now, but I’m not sure I’d want the value of my next coffee going up and down by 20-40% each time.
Finally, with the proliferation of other alternative coins, it’s hard to see the future clear enough to judge Bitcoin’s value.
Conclusion on Bitcoin
For me, it’s a fascinating experiment in markets, consumer trends and market manipulation. At the peak of the crypto boom you couldn’t sit in a tea room without hearing the opinions of an overnight crypto expert. Hopefully, investors have learned from the dramatic rise and fall of Bitcoin, and in future will avoid getting swept up in ‘get-rich-quick’ rhetoric.
During the hysteria in December, I provided readers a potential way of valuing Bitcoin using its market capitalisation relative to other markets. The concept still holds up, so for those interested, you can read that here.
About Josh Callaghan
Canstar’s General Manager for Wealth, Josh Callaghan, has accumulated more than 15 years’ experience in banking and finance, with in-depth product knowledge across retail banking, stockbroking, life insurance, health insurance and superannuation. Josh’s experience combined with his passion for new technology and active role in the fintech community has positioned him as a credible thought-leader on the future of finance. Through his work at Canstar, Josh is striving towards a goal of creating a world where building and managing wealth is easy for all consumers.