Travel Money Cards vs. Credit and Debit Cards vs. Cash

Co-author: TJ Ryan

If overseas adventures are on your bucket list – and here’s why they should be – know that choosing the right card for your travels can potentially save you some extra spending money. Currency conversion fees, initial card fees, purchase fees and ATM fees can eat away at your hard-earned travel savings while you’re off gallivanting, leaving you with less money to make the most out of your trip.

With cash and travellers cheques fast becoming a thing of the past for overseas spenders, the three main ways of spending money overseas are via travel money cards, credit cards and debit cards. The costs and features associated these different types of cards can wildly differ, so it’s important to compare each option carefully.

There are two very important issues that you need to know about first off: load times and pre-authorisations of certain payments.

Do travel cards have different load times?

Yes. Travel money cards can take up to 3 days to make funds available when you transfer more money onto your card in a reload. This is not ideal because it can leave you stranded if you do not have another payment method with you and you have run out of money on that card.

How do travel cards deal with pre-authorisations?

Pre-authorisations are where money is “held” on a card by a merchant in advance of the actual payment being made. This typically happens with hotel check-in and hiring a rental car, and it means that effectively two payments are charged to the card and reduce your available balance – a pre-authorisation payment that secures payment for the expected cost of your hotel stay or your car hire, and then a second authorisation that takes payment for the actual cost of your stay or hire from your card.

This is fine if you’re using a travel credit card because you have money available up to your credit limit, and the pre-authorisation payment is usually only held on the card for a day or a week at most. In contrast, if you are using a travel debit card or a travel money card, the pre-authorisation payment can be held for up to a month.

If you’re low on funds, these two authorisation payments could wipe your card out until the first pre-authorisation payment is released up to 30 days later. You’d probably be home from your trip by then! This means less money for you to use travelling, and even worse, if you want to transfer the leftover money off your card and into your normal bank account when you return, a refund fee is typically charged!

Travel Money Cards: Pros and Cons

Benefits of a travel money card…

• Locked in exchange rate: When you load money onto your travel money card before your trip, you’ll be locking in an exchange rate for those funds. Being able to lock in an exchange rate means you don’t have to worry about the fluctuating value of the Aussie Dollar. This will help give you certainty when planning your trip budget.

• Load multiple currencies: If you’re visiting a few different countries in one trip, a travel money card could be useful because it allows you to load multiple currencies. Spending in the local currency means you’re not paying conversion fees every time you make a transaction. The Commonwealth Bank’s Travel Money Card allows you to load up to 13 currencies at a given point (at the time of writing).

• Less risk: Since it’s not a card for your general banking needs, you’ll only ever use a travel money card for your overseas spending. So if it is stolen, there is no risk to your money above what you loaded onto the card – thieves can’t access your salary or savings.

Potential Cons of a travel money card:

• Exchange rates: According to Canstar’s analysis, the exchange rates (excluding currency conversion fees) for loading and reloading travel money cards vary, with some being less favourable than the exchange rates on travel credit cards and debit cards. What’s more, if you do run out of one currency on the card and have to use another, the exchange rate you pay on the currency conversion is the live rate not your locked in rates.

• Higher fees: In general, there are higher fees for travel money cards. Fees include purchase fees, issue fees, load and reload fees, fees when cashing out the remaining balance, and ATM fees.

• Load times: It can take up to 3 days to load money onto a travel money card, which can leave you stuck waiting without money in a foreign country if your card balance is low.
• Pre-authorisations: Hotels and rental car hire pre-authorisations (see above) are more difficult for travel money cards because they are pre-paid. As discussed above, the two authorisation payments could leave you without money on your card for up to 30 days.

What travel money cards does Canstar compare?

When comparing travel money card products, Canstar’s Star Ratings may prove useful. In its 2020 Ratings, Canstar Research assessed 14 travel money cards on our database based on price and features, and gave 5-Star Ratings to the products found to offer outstanding value. These were:

• Citi Global Currency Account
• HSBC Everyday Global Account
• Travelex Money Card

Compare Travel Money Cards

Does a travel money card sound like the way to go? You can preview the current market offerings in our comparison table below. This table has been forumlated based on a trip to the USA, and sorted by the star rating provided by Canstar (highest to lowest).

Credit Cards

Credit cards also have both good and perhaps not so good features to be aware of when you’re travelling overseas.

Benefits of a credit card:

• Good exchange rates: Some credit card providers offer exchange rates that are very close to the actual spot rate. This is especially the case on the few cards that don’t charge currency conversion fees. (It’s not true of all cards though, so do your homework.)

• More funds available: Funds are available to use up to your credit limit, which is good for hotel and car hire pre-authorisations, and for emergencies.

• Concierge services: The concierge services on premium credit cards can help with requests and bookings while you’re away on holiday.
• Pre-authorisations: Credit card pre-authorisation payments are usually only held on the card balance for a day or a week, compared to up to a month for debit cards and travel money cards.

Potential cons of a credit card:

• ATM fees: It can be very costly to withdraw from an ATM overseas using a credit card. You may be hit with a cash advance fee (potentially around 3%) and interest will begin accruing as soon as you withdraw the money, on top of the ATM fee and the currency conversion fee. Again, this is not true of all cards though.

• Temptation to overspend: Since funds are available to use up to your credit limit, you may be tempted to spend more than you budgeted for and find yourself paying off your holiday over many months at high interest rates.

Compare Travel Credit and Debit Cards

Debit Cards

Some people prefer debit to credit – but again there are pros and cons…

Benefits of debit cards:

• Cheaper ATM access: It’s generally cheaper to withdraw money from an ATM overseas using a debit card rather than a credit card, particularly if your bank belongs to an international ATM network such as Citi. Some debit cards allow completely free withdrawals from supported ATMs all over the world.

• Good exchange rates: Along with credit cards, debit cards also generally offer better exchange rates than travel money cards (excluding currency conversion fees), according to Canstar’s analysis.

• More control: Since you are accessing your own money, you more are in control of your spending.

Possible cons of debit cards:

• Less protection: If you are a victim of fraud, your money could be tied up while the dispute is resolved, leaving you without access to your funds.

• Pre-authorisations: Some businesses like hotels or car rental agencies might not accept debit cards for pre-authorisations.

 

Compare Travel Credit and Debit Cards

 

Cash

Sometimes it’s good to get back to basics…

Benefits of carrying cash:

• Budgeting: It’s so easy to budget for a short trip when you have an envelope of cash for each day and that is literally all you have to spend. Of course, some days may be more expensive if you want to do a certain experience or buy a large souvenir, but you know you have to spend less in the days beforehand or afterwards in order to have enough money that day.

• Exchange rates and fees: Assuming you bought your cash in the right currencies before you left, you’re done – no more currency conversion fees as you go, no more ATM fees, and no more worrying about exchange rates.

Possible cons of using cash:

• Less protection: If you are a victim of pick-pocketing or other theft, your money is gone, leaving you without access to your funds. We already recommend that people travelling with cash also have another payment method available such as a credit card for emergencies.

• Pre-authorisations: Some businesses like hotels or car rental agencies will still require a credit card for pre-authorisations.
• Inflexible: Want to spend a little more than you budgeted for? Well you can’t, unless you also brought a credit card with you.

 Learn more about Credit Cards

• My credit card comes with travel insurance – is it worth it?
• Are rewards credit cards worth it?