Why investing in bonds can still be worthwhile

As an investor, it can be worrying when returns move into negative territory. Many of us are used to seeing that with share investments, but it’s less common when it comes to high-quality, investment-grade bonds.

In recent months, however, that’s exactly what’s been happening with bonds. The prices on government bonds, which are generally regarded as relatively risk-free investment securities, have been falling. This comes at a time when the income returns from government bonds remain quite low. So, why have the trading prices of bonds (fixed interest securities) been falling on markets?

What’s happening with bonds?

What’s actually happening with bond prices at the moment is being driven by rising growth and future growth expectations across developed economies such as Australia. Governments around the world have been stimulating growth by pumping huge amounts of capital into their economies to counter the debilitating financial effects of the COVID-19 pandemic. But a counter effect of doing this, is that if economic growth moves too quickly it can lead to higher inflation. This may then require central banks such as our Reserve Bank to lift official interest rates to ensure the economy doesn’t become too overheated. While central banks have poured cold water over the prospects of official rates rising anytime soon, it’s these expectations that have driven a rise in government bond yields. And that’s resulted in a corresponding fall in bond market prices.

Are negative bond returns a concern?

Negative price returns from bonds are certainly nothing new and, to illustrate that, it’s useful to look back to historical events between 1994 and 1996. As shown in the chart below, Australian 10-year bond returns fell into negative territory in 1994 as bond yields (interest rates) rose. But, over the course of 1995 and 1996, bond returns rose sharply as yields declined from their peak above 10 per cent.

Source: Bloomberg Ausbond Composite 0+ Year Index from 1/1/1994 – 31/12/1996

Bond yields are shown on the green line and left-hand axis, and annualised bond performance is shown on the three green bars.

While there is less scope for a sharp fall in bond yields as experienced in 1995 and 1996 given the current overall lower yield environment, it’s still important to focus on the role of having fixed income (bonds) in a diversified portfolio.

Understanding the role of bonds

On a risk-return basis, bonds sit below shares and above cash. Equity market returns have been rising strongly over the past year since the huge sell-offs on global share markets in February-March last year. With the strong growth comes a higher element of risk. Being lower risk than shares, bond returns are generally expected to underperform shares over the long term. Likewise, being slightly higher risk than cash held in savings and term deposit accounts, bonds are generally expected to outperform cash over the long term.

It’s important to understand that one of the key roles of bonds in an investment portfolio is to offset the higher risk inherent in shares.
Bond returns tend to move in the opposite direction to shares and play a valuable role in protecting near-term downside risk when the share market performs worse than expected over short periods. They tend to act as a buffer to volatility in shares. In other words, they provide asset class diversification to help smooth out total investment returns over time.

While bonds do not generally outperform riskier asset classes such as shares over the long run, they have a more stable return profile.
In addition, having exposure to bonds with longer maturity dates (for example, 10-year bonds and longer) than shorter-term securities (one year or less) provides further protection, because longer-term securities tend to perform better when equities perform poorly.
This introduces the benefits of investing into bond index funds, which have holdings in a wide range of bond issues that have different maturity dates. As individual bond issues reach their maturity date over time, investments can be purchased in new bond issues with higher yields. This increases the prospects for future income.

Investing in bonds during a time of rising yields, as we’re seeing now, can deliver higher income returns. This may be attractive to those seeking higher income in the future. While seeing a negative price return from fixed interest securities is not overly common, keep in mind that asset class returns do invariably change on a continual basis. Having broad exposure to the stronger performance from equities will deliver growing investment returns over time and provide diversification. But if there are events that cause a sharp fall on equity markets, as we experienced last year, a flight to safe and quality investments, such as government bonds, will continue to reduce portfolio volatility.

Your overall portfolio allocation to different assets ultimately comes back to your investment goals and risk profile, and more specifically to your overall time frame.

If you’re comparing online share trading companies, the comparison table below displays some of the companies available on Canstar’s database with links to providers’ websites. The information displayed is based on an average of six trades per month. Please note the table is sorted by Star Rating (highest to lowest), followed by provider name (alphabetical). Use Canstar’s Online Share Trading comparison selector to view a wider range of online share trading companies.

Main image: Elena_Dig (Shutterstock.com)


Thanks for visiting Canstar, Australia’s biggest financial comparison site*

→ Looking more ways to create wealth? Learn more about Online Share Trading, Exchange Traded Funds and Cryptocurrency.

You can also compare health insurancecredit cards and life insurance, as well as home loans, with Canstar.

This article was reviewed by our Content Producer Marissa Hayden before it was updated, as part of our fact-checking process.


Tony Kaye is Senior Personal Finance Writer at Vanguard. He was a former manager at Standard & Poor’s Ratings and has a regular column in the Australian's Wealth section. He has a Bachelor of Arts and Journalism at Curtin University and Public Relations at RMIT University.

Similar Topics:

Share this article